What if God/the Divine/the Creative Force of the Universe/the Mystery, loves the entire Universe, as opposed to just sections of it?
What if Love has nothing to do with fear and/or punishment, as opposed to using fear and/or punishment to push people toward Love?
What if humanity is saved/redeemed/healed/made whole/by Grace, as opposed to some kind of payment and/or sacrifice?
What if being born again has more to do with being made aware of what God is, what Love is, what Grace is, as opposed to measuring up?
What if the sheep are the universalists as opposed to the goats who are not?
Of course these are all just fun hypotheticals...